top of page
Families navigating end-of-life and serious illness care

Across the Field

Advance Care Planning 

What It Is

Advance care planning (ACP) is a process that prepares people and their medical decision-makers for communication and medical decision-making. It helps adults at any age or stage of health understand and share their values, life goals, and preferences for medical care. It starts with what quality of life means to the individual and helps people and families prepare for medical decisions and difficult trade-offs that may arise as health changes.


In practice, advance care planning can include thinking about what quality of life means to the individual, choosing and preparing someone trusted to make medical decisions if the person cannot speak for themselves, talking with family and clinicians, and documenting preferences for future medical care in an advance directive.

​

A comprehensive approach to advance care planning can include:

Education for people and families about advance care planning and why it matters.

Conversations about what matters most, including values, goals, and preferences.

Ways to document preferences for future medical care and identify a medical decision-maker in an advance directive. An advance directive may include a living will that describes a person’s wishes and preferences for future care, a durable power of attorney for health care that names someone to make medical decisions if the person cannot speak for themselves, or both.

Systems that make this information available when and where medical decisions need to be made, including electronic health records, interoperable registries, health information exchanges, and secure third-party platforms that allow advance directives and Physician Orders for Life-Sustaining Treatment or Medical Orders for Life-Sustaining Treatment (POLST/MOLST) forms to be shared across care settings.

Education for people and families about advance care planning and why it matters.

Training for clinicians and community educators to support these conversations.

For people living with serious illness or advanced frailty, ways to translate current treatment preferences into medical orders, such as a Physician Orders for Life-Sustaining Treatment or Medical Orders for Life-Sustaining Treatment (POLST/MOLST), when appropriate.

Opportunities to revisit conversations, update preferences as health, circumstances, and priorities change, and make sure the current information is shared with the medical decision maker and care team.

Where It Fits

People can begin advance care planning at any stage of adulthood and return to it over time as their health, circumstances, and priorities change. Early conversations may focus on what quality of life means to the individual, preferences for future medical care, and choosing and preparing a trusted medical decision-maker. As health changes, planning can become more specific and connect more directly to decisions about current care.


Advance care planning and serious illness conversations can overlap and build on one another. Advance care planning emphasizes preparation for communication and medical decision-making across the life course, including understanding what matters most, choosing and preparing a trusted medical decision-maker, and documenting preferences in advance. As serious illness develops, serious illness conversations bring the person's current condition, prognosis, treatment options, and trade-offs more directly into the discussion.


The philanthropic opportunities also overlap. Advance care planning often emphasizes community engagement, public education, planning tools, and preparing individuals and trusted decision makers. In comparison, serious illness communication places greater emphasis on the clinical workforce and care delivery systems needed to support conversations as illness progresses.

Why It Matters

Many medical decisions arise as a person’s health changes, sometimes when they are too sick to speak for themselves. Families and trusted medical decision-makers may then be asked to make difficult choices about treatments, hospitalization, procedures, or comfort-focused care. Advance care planning helps people prepare by giving them time to think about what matters most, talk with the people they trust, and prepare someone to speak for them if needed. It can help people receive medical care that reflects their values, goals, and preferences, while reducing stress and uncertainty for those who may need to make decisions on their behalf.

Story

Bringing Advance Care Planning

Into the Community

After facing cancer herself, Helen became an Advance Care Planning Ambassador at Self Help for the Elderly. Today, she helps older adults in San Francisco’s Chinese community talk with their families, choose someone they trust to speak for them, and begin planning for future medical decisions.


Her story shows what can happen when trusted people within a community lead advance care planning.

​

Watch Helen’s Story >

What the Evidence Shows

Measuring

What Matters Most

A review of 69 randomized controlled trials conducted between 2010 and 2020 found the most consistent benefits in helping people prepare for future decisions and communicate their wishes. Studies also found consistent benefits in satisfaction with communication and care and reductions in distress among family decision makers.  In contrast, findings for outcomes such as goal-concordant care, quality of life, and health care utilization were less consistent.

 

Goal-concordant care, meaning care consistent with a person's goals and preferences, has long been viewed as an important outcome of advance care planning and serious illness conversations. Yet understanding the full impact of these approaches can be difficult because some of their most meaningful outcomes are also among the hardest to measure.


The challenge is structural. Measuring goal concordance requires tracking two things that can change over time: a person's goals, which may evolve as illness progresses, and the care they receive, which unfolds across many decisions, clinicians, and care settings. Researchers continue to debate when to assess goals, whose perspective to use, and how to determine whether a specific treatment decision reflected a person's evolving preferences. Even trained clinicians reviewing the same medical record may reach different conclusions about whether care was concordant. (Ernecoff et al., Journal of Pain and Symptom Management, 2021)

Assessing concordance requires understanding the meaning behind a person's words and how their preferences evolve. This makes it much harder to measure than simpler quality indicators, such as whether an advance directive is documented. Until recently, evaluating goal-concordant care has often required labor-intensive manual chart review to interpret free-text clinical notes, track changes in goals across encounters, and compare those goals with subsequent treatment decisions.


New research is beginning to test whether artificial intelligence can help make this type of measurement more feasible at scale. See Understanding the Role of AI Across Solutions for what the research shows and what funders should consider before investing.


Funders should also be cautious about relying on health care utilization as it is shaped by many factors beyond advance care planning, including access to care, available services, symptom burden, and broader structural inequities. Recent expert consensus recommends assessing other clinically meaningful outcomes, including burden and distress among medical decision makers, whether patients feel heard and understood, and satisfaction with care, communication, and decision-making. (Hickman et al., Journal of the American Geriatrics Society, 2023)

Where the Field Stands

Progress

Advance care planning has evolved from a primary focus on documenting end-of-life decisions and preferences for life-sustaining treatment toward a broader approach to preparing people and families for communication and medical decision-making across the life course. It can begin when people are healthy or living with chronic illness and continue as they experience serious illness or approach the end of life.

​

Today, advance care planning increasingly emphasizes ongoing conversations about what matters most, preparing trusted medical decision makers, engaging families and communities, and documenting values, goals, and preferences for medical care. The field is also increasingly placing advance care planning within a broader continuum of care planning that includes both decisions made in advance and decisions that arise in the moment as health changes. This approach recognizes that people and families may need different kinds of preparation at different stages of life, shaped by what quality of life means to the person, their readiness to engage, and the medical decisions they face.

1

More community-based models

Senior centers, faith communities, cultural organizations, and other trusted community settings are helping bring advance care planning to people who may have limited opportunities to engage through the health care system or who may prefer to begin these conversations in places and with people they already know. Community-based approaches can make it easier to provide support in a person's preferred language and in ways that reflect cultural values, family relationships, and different approaches to medical decision-making. They also bring community health workers, navigators, faith leaders, social workers, attorneys, and other trusted community experts into the work alongside clinicians. Increasingly, communities are also helping shape the programs themselves. In San Francisco, for example, the Learning Journeys project partnered separately with the city's Black, Chinese, and Latino communities. Each community formed its own advisory committee and designed and led advance care planning events based on its priorities, experiences, and preferred ways of engaging.

2

Better tools and technology

Evidence-based programs such as PREPARE for Your Care help people think through what matters to them, identify questions, and feel more prepared to talk with family members and their care team. Electronic health records, registries, and greater interoperability can also help make important information available when and where decisions need to be made.

3

A Medicare payment pathway exists

A Medicare payment pathway exists. Medicare reimburses clinicians for advance care planning through CPT codes 99497 and 99498, creating a payment pathway for these conversations. Payment alone, however, does not address other barriers such as limited time, training, workflows, and organizational support.

Gaps

Despite progress, advance care planning is still far from routine, and access remains uneven.

1

Clinicians need more time and support

Many clinicians lack adequate time, training, workflows, and organizational support to make these conversations routine and ensure consistent quality. Existing payment mechanisms do not address all of these barriers.

2

Decision makers need preparation

Naming a medical decision maker is an important first step. That person also needs to understand what matters most to the individual, feel prepared to ask questions and speak on their behalf, and make difficult choices based on the person’s values and wishes, even when those differ from their own.

3

Implementation remains uneven

Even effective advance care planning approaches can be difficult to integrate into routine practice. Success requires clear roles and workflows, leadership support, community partnerships, appropriate technology, and ongoing evaluation and adaptation. More investment is needed to understand how to implement proven approaches effectively across different populations, organizations, and settings.

4

Documentation remains an imperfect measure of preparation

The field increasingly views advance care planning as an ongoing process grounded in conversations about values, goals, and preferences. In practice, advance directive completion remains one of the most visible and commonly measured markers of advance care planning. For example, the federal quality measure "Advance Care Plan" asks clinicians to report whether an advance care plan or discussion is documented for patients age 65 and older. It does not assess the quality of the conversation, how well a medical decision maker has been prepared, or whether the person ultimately receives care aligned with their goals and preferences. Documentation remains important because wishes need to be available when decisions arise. Advance directives also cannot anticipate every medical situation a person may face, which makes conversations about values, priorities, and how to approach unexpected decisions especially important.

5

Many people are still left out

White older adults are significantly more likely to have an advance directive (44 percent) than Black older adults (24 percent) or Hispanic older adults (29 percent). Communities of color, immigrant communities, rural communities, people with limited English proficiency, people with disabilities, people experiencing homelessness, and people with limited access to trusted care may have fewer opportunities to engage in advance care planning. Language, trust, geography, access to health care, and other barriers continue to shape who has meaningful opportunities to plan ahead.

6

Community-based advance care planning lacks sustainable funding

Some of the most trusted places for these conversations are outside the health care system, including faith communities, senior centers, cultural organizations, and other community-based organizations. Yet these settings often lack reliable funding or reimbursement, leaving important work dependent on short-term grants or volunteer labor.

Where Philanthropy Can Help

Funders can support advance care planning through several of the tactics described in Putting Solutions into Practice:

Engagement and Communication

1

Build public understanding of advance care planning.

Help people understand what advance care planning is, why it matters throughout adulthood, and how to begin. Support education that addresses common misconceptions, including assumptions that loved ones will automatically know what someone wants, planning is only relevant near the end of life, or completing a legal document completes the process.

2

Bring advance care planning into trusted community settings.

Support community-led education through community health workers, care navigators, faith leaders, cultural organizations, and other trusted messengers, particularly for people who may not be reached through health systems or mainstream media.

3

Make conversations about future medical decisions more common.

Support public awareness campaigns, including around National Healthcare Decisions Day, that encourage people and families to talk before a crisis.

Workforce, Capacity, and Care Delivery

1

Build the community workforce for advance care planning.

Train and support community educators, navigators, and other trusted messengers to lead advance care planning education and help people take next steps.

2

Integrate advance care planning into routine health care.

Support leadership, defined roles, workflows, referral systems, and community partnerships that make care planning a consistent part of practice.

3

Make planning information available when it is needed.

Fund processes and infrastructure that help advance directives and other care planning information move across settings, including registries, electronic health record integration, and interoperability improvements.

Innovation and Model Design

1

Develop and evaluate community-led approaches.

Support models designed with and delivered through trusted community organizations that can reach people earlier and in places where they already have relationships.

2

Test digital and AI-supported tools carefully.

Evaluate tools that help people reflect on their priorities, prepare for conversations, complete planning steps, or share information with clinicians, with attention to effectiveness, equity, accessibility, privacy, and usability. See Understanding the Role of AI Across Solutions for questions to consider before funding these tools. (Add link.)

Scaling and Replication

1

Expand proven approaches to more communities and settings.

Support training, technical assistance, translation, cultural adaptation, partnerships, and implementation that allow effective approaches to reach new populations and geographies.

2

Sustain shared tools and resources the field depends on.

Fund the ongoing maintenance, updating, translation, technology, evaluation, and dissemination of evidence-based tools and resources that are freely available to people, communities, and care organizations.

Payment, Policy, Research, and Evidence

1

Improve payment for high-quality advance care planning.

Support payment approaches that recognize the time and skill required for meaningful planning conversations and help make them a routine part of care.

2

Build sustainable funding for community-based advance care planning.

Explore health care payment models and existing aging-services funding streams, including opportunities within Older Americans Act Title III programs, that can support community education and navigation over time.

3

Strengthen the evidence for what works.

Fund research and evaluation that examine which approaches work best, for whom, in which settings, and at what points in the life course.

4

Measure outcomes that matter to people and families.

Support measures that capture whether people feel prepared, whether trusted decision makers are informed and ready, whether planning information is available when needed, and whether care reflects a person’s goals and priorities.

Find Organizations Doing this Work

See organizations funded by the Serious Illness and End-of-Life Funders Community working to advance Advance Care Planning in the Organization Directory. 

Resources for Deeper Learning

1

The Care Planning Umbrella: The Evolution of Advance Care Planning

Hickman, Lum, Walling, Savoy, and Sudore, Journal of the American Geriatrics Society, 2023

Offers a framework for understanding advance care planning as part of a broader continuum of care planning across the life course. The authors describe the field’s evolution from a primary focus on documenting future treatment preferences toward preparing people and medical decision makers for communication and medical decision-making, with quality of life and what matters most to the individual at the center.

2

Dying in America: Improving Quality and Honoring Individual Preferences Near the End of Life, Chapter 3: “Clinician-Patient Communication and Advance Care Planning”

Institute of Medicine, 2015

Provides a systems-level overview of advance care planning and communication, including barriers to participation, elements of high-quality conversations, the roles of families and medical decision makers, community-wide approaches, and the health system and policy changes needed to make planning a routine part of care.

3

Deconstructing the Complexities of Advance Care Planning Outcomes: What Do We Know and Where Do We Go? A Scoping Review

McMahan, Tellez, and Sudore, Journal of the American Geriatrics Society, 2021

Reviews 69 randomized controlled trials of advance care planning and provides a useful framework for understanding what ACP has been shown to accomplish. The review found the most consistent benefits in helping people take steps to prepare for future decisions, improving satisfaction with communication and care, and reducing distress among family decision makers. In contrast, findings for goal-concordant care, quality of life, and health care utilization were less consistent. It is particularly useful for funders considering what outcomes ACP programs should reasonably be expected to achieve and measure.

4

PREPARE for Your Care

University of California, San Francisco

A freely available, evidence-based advance care planning program designed to help people identify what matters most, choose and prepare a medical decision maker, talk with family members and clinicians, and document their preferences. PREPARE was designed with health literacy and accessibility in mind and is available in multiple languages. A randomized clinical trial among diverse English- and Spanish-speaking adults in safety-net primary care found that PREPARE increased ACP engagement and documentation compared with an easy-to-read advance directive alone.

5

The Conversation Project

Institute for Healthcare Improvement

Offers free tools that help people begin conversations about what matters most, choose and prepare a health care decision maker, talk with their health care team, and support family members serving in the decision-maker role. The Conversation Project also provides facilitation guides and other resources that community organizations can use to bring advance care planning conversations into workplaces, faith communities, senior centers, and other community settings.

Explore the resources: The Conversation Project

6

Community-Based Advance Care Planning Interventions for Minority Older Adults: A Systematic Review

Estrada, Cohen, Shang, and Stone, Journal of Gerontological Nursing, 2021

Reviews community-based advance care planning interventions developed for racially and ethnically diverse older adults. The studies included culturally tailored approaches delivered in Asian American and Latino communities through workshops and one-on-one support. The review found promising results for advance directive completion, ACP knowledge, beliefs, and attitudes, while also highlighting how limited the evidence remains across diverse populations. It provides a useful starting point for funders interested in community-led, culturally and linguistically responsive approaches and in strengthening the evidence behind them.

7

Learning Journeys: Lessons from a Community-Driven Approach to Advance Care Planning

Supportive Care Collaborative and University of California, San Francisco, 2023

Documents a community-led effort to understand and strengthen advance care planning among Black, Chinese, and Latino communities in San Francisco. Community members helped identify barriers and trusted approaches, develop culturally and linguistically responsive messages and tools, and design and test engagement strategies in settings where people already gather. The project offers funders a practical example of investing in community leadership, trusted messengers, culturally responsive program design, and research at the same time. Three peer-reviewed studies examine the approaches and findings within each participating community.

8

National POLST Collaborative

An independent 501(c)3 non-profit organization

Provides guidance on how Physician Orders for Life-Sustaining Treatment and Medical Orders for Life-Sustaining Treatment fit within the broader care planning continuum for people with progressing serious illness or advanced frailty. Resources include guidance for patients and clinicians, state-specific POLST programs and forms, implementation resources, and approaches to improving the accessibility and portability of medical orders across care settings.

Explore the resource: National POLST Collaborative

Explore More Solutions

or Navigate to the Main Sections

Use the naviation buttons to explore more solutions or navigate back to the Main Sections. 

bottom of page